You are here

Modals with 'have'


Level: intermediate

We can use a modal verb with have and a past participle:

Subject Modal have Past participle  
They will have arrived by now.
You might have seen the film.
Jack and Jill would have been late.

We use a modal verb with have:

  • to refer back from the present:

It's nearly eight o'clock. They will have arrived by now.

  • to refer back from a point of time in the past:

We were very worried. We thought someone might have taken the car.

  • to refer back from a point of time in the future:

We won't eat until they arrive. They might not have had supper.

  • to refer to past time:

You should have helped her when she asked.
They might have got lost. Nobody knows where they are.

Modal verbs with have 1


Modal verbs with have 2




Hello everyone!
What's the difference with modal and without modal?  I mean 'They will have arrived by now' and 'They have arrived by now'  I have this question for only modal verb 'will and would'.
Thank you.

Hi bimsara,

will have arrived is a future perfect form and have arrived is a present perfect form. The present perfect is explained in detail on our present perfect page, and both are explained on our perfective aspect page. Once you've read through these pages, please let us know if you have any other questions.

Best wishes,

The LearnEnglish Team

Dear Professional Team,
Firstly, let me express my interest in this site. 
Secondly, please help explain the difference between: might have and may have for me in this sentence:
However hard Mealy tried to phone Jack, there was no answer. It was possible that Jack was out.
A. Jack must have gone out      B. Jack might have gone out          
C. Jack should have gone out    D. Jack may have gone out.
Thanks and best regards, 

Hello Uyen Bui,

In my opinion there is no difference in this context.  In fact, in most contexts 'may have' and 'might have' are interchangeable - both are possible.  The exception to this is when we have a situation in which we know the outcome, and we want to speculate about an alternative reality.  For example:

Mealy tried to phone Jack, but there was no answer.

Jack might have gone out. (correct)

Jay may have gone out. (correct)

Now imagine that we know the situation: we know that Jack was out when we called, and want to think about alternatives.

Jack was out when we called.

A call ten minutes earlier might have caught him. (correct)

A call ten minutes earlier may have caught him. (incorrect)


I hope that helps to answer your question.

Best wishes,



The LearnEnglish Team

Hi..every one!!! I'm from srilanka... i studied @ universty of moratwa..colombo..... i like to improve english language through this learn english team.... could you all help me to imprpve my language skill...??? i will share that i know... and i want help from you all...
Thak you!!!

hello every one i think we should contact and communicate with us to increase skills  in addition learn more from the best website  ..
best regards

I think that  I should have help to understand this new lenguage

Hello everyone, I'm from Georgian (I'm Georgian, not American :d)
What is the best way to improve your communication skills in English?
I know how to say correctly but when I speak I do mistakes
I'm waiting for advices... thank you!!!

do not worry about mistakes it is important to learn more from mistakes to be good speaker

i m Sami Michel from syria 
i m  trying to improve my skills in english  <
i wish i could communicate with a friends < and speak english with them