At an art market, Ash and Stephen find themselves in an argument about who is the better artist. They decide to have a competition, but first they need to find out what art is.

Instructions

Do the Preparation task first. Then watch the video. Next go to the Tasks and do the activities. If you need help, you can read the Transcript at any time.

Task 1

Order the sentences according to the video.

Exercise

Task 2

Decide if these statements are true or false.

Exercise

Task 3

Order the words to make useful expressions from the video.

Exercise

Download

Tags

Comments

I would appreciate a brief tutorial on the use of the word "would" in the following manner:
(1) "I wish I would have" [instead of "I wish I had"]
and
(2) "if he would have done it differently" [instead of "if he had done it differently"]

In each case the use of "would" in the sentence is superfluous and redundant, but what, grammaticaly, is wrong with using "would" instead of simply using the past perfect participle or (if I have it right) the future perfect participle?

I hear it and read it often but can't explain the actual grammatical deficiency.

Can some one help with this.

Hello Faustus,

The standard form here is 'I wish I had...' and 'If he had...', as you suggest. The use of 'would have' here is not a standard form and is either an error or a dialectical feature.

We express past hypothetical situations using a backwards tense shift in English (past > past perfect) rather than the modal auxiliary 'would'. The modal auxiliary is used in the counterfactual result clause:

If + past perfect (past hypothetical condition) > would have + past participle (counterfactual result)

If I had received the invitiation I would have gone to the party.

If I hadn't lost my wallet I wouldn't have had such problems.

I can't give you a reason why this is so as, ultimately, all such grammatical structures are arbitrary, of course. This is standard use, however, and the error or non-standard element in the sentences you quote is the use of a form in the condition clause which belongs in the result clause.

 

Best wishes,

Peter

The LearnEnglish Team

Hello again, everyone.
Yes in my country that usually there are few Arts Gallery some of them in the center of the city and another is different parts of the town,There is even a shop with art galleries that open almost everyday, but my favorite one is the market art gallery that is organized by students. They and young people could come here and sell art that they made it,usually here you can find some paintings and objects handmade crafts.
What about me I don't think so I have any art talents but if I think about a few years behaind I think I had, but you know it doesn't matter if you have just the talent, you have to work constantly at that and to develop yourself all the time to be really good at art.
As I said already for a good artist, you have to work really really hard and not just for one week for one year you have to work many many years to be a good painter or a good singer.
Bye for now, good luck and see you next time.

I don't know if there's open air Art markets in my country, May be.
I love dance Tango but I don't think I have any artistic talents in other arts like painting, sculpture, woodworking....
When Art makes you have a good feeling, strong emotions, bad or good, this makes it a good art. ( Hi Peter or Kirk, could you tell me if my last sentence is correct or is there a better way to say it, please, thank you)

Hello STEPHANE ROTH,

Your last sentence is not quite grammatically correct but is clear in terms of what you are trying to say. I would change it as follows:

When art gives you a good feeling, which is to say strong emotions whether bad or good, then I would say it is good art.

 

Best wishes,

Peter

The LearnEnglish Team

Hi!There is famous open-air art market Andriyivskiy uzvyz in Kiev, Ukraine. There lots of artists show and sell their art. I'm not really can art. I think for good art need to have wonderful imagination.

Hello,everyone!!! I like to painting by number. It makes me relax,but i can't painting long time...now i want to learn drawing...

Yes, there are open-air markets in my country. I don't know I have any artistic talents or not. I just draw and paint because it makes me happy and free and full of live. I think a couple of hand which make their works happily and pleasurably create good art.

Yes, there are.
I used to draw some pictures by Van Gogh but I have lost my talent.
It must have got the colours that makes you happy and refreshed.

ı havent got any ability about draw but ı love art and ı want to do drawing

Pages