You are here

The broken mirror, the black cat and lots of good luck

Nikos was an ordinary man. One thing that he did not believe in was superstition. But when so many things that are meant to cause bad luck started bringing him good luck, he began to wonder …

Do the preparation task first. Then read the story and do the exercises.

Nikos was an ordinary man. Nothing particularly good ever happened to him; nothing particularly bad ever happened to him. He went through life accepting the mixture of good things and bad things that happen to everyone. He never looked for any explanation or reason about why things happened just the way they did.

One thing, however, that Nikos absolutely did not believe in was superstition. He had no time for superstition, no time at all. Nikos thought himself to be a very rational man, a man who did not believe that his good luck or bad luck was in any way changed by black cats, walking under ladders, spilling salt or opening umbrellas inside the house.

Nikos spent much of his time in the small taverna near where he lived. In the taverna he sat drinking coffee and talking to his friends. Sometimes his friends played dice or cards. Sometimes they played for money. Some of them made bets on horse races or football matches. But Nikos never did. He didn’t know much about sport, so he didn’t think he could predict the winners. And he absolutely didn’t believe in chance or luck or superstition, like a lot of his friends did.

One morning Nikos woke up and walked into the bathroom. He started to shave, as he did every morning, but as he was shaving he noticed that the mirror on the bathroom wall wasn’t quite straight. He tried to move it to one side to make it straighter, but as soon as he touched it, the mirror fell off the wall and hit the floor with a huge crash. It broke into a thousand pieces. Nikos knew that some people thought this was unlucky. ‘Seven years’ bad luck,’ they said, when a mirror broke. But Nikos wasn’t superstitious. Nikos wasn’t superstitious at all. He didn’t care. He thought superstition was nonsense. He picked up the pieces of the mirror, put them in the bin and finished shaving without a mirror.

After that he went into the kitchen to make himself a sandwich to take to work for his lunch. He cut two pieces of bread and put some cheese on them. Then he thought he needed some salt. When he picked up the salt jar, it fell from his hand and broke on the floor. Salt was everywhere. Some people, he knew, thought that this was also supposed to bring bad luck. But Nikos didn’t care. He didn’t believe in superstitions.

He left the house and went to work. On his way to work he saw a black cat running away from him. He didn’t care. He wasn’t superstitious. Some builders were working on a house on his street. There was a ladder across the pavement. Nikos thought about walking around the ladder, but he didn’t care; he wasn’t superstitious and didn’t believe in superstitions, so he walked right underneath the ladder.

Even though Nikos wasn’t superstitious, he thought that something bad was certain to happen to him today. He had broken a mirror, spilled some salt, walked under a ladder and seen a black cat running away from him. He told everybody at work what had happened. ‘Something bad will happen to you today!’ they all said. But nothing bad happened to him.

That evening, as usual, he went to the taverna. He told all his friends in the taverna that he had broken a mirror, spilled the salt, seen a black cat running away from him and then walked under a ladder. All his friends in the taverna moved away from him. ‘Something bad will happen to him,’ they all said, ‘and we don’t want to be near him when it happens!’

But nothing bad happened to Nikos all evening. He sat there as normal, and everything was normal. Nikos was waiting for something bad to happen to him. But it didn’t.

‘Nikos, come and play cards with us!’ joked one of his friends. ‘I’m sure to win!’ Nikos didn’t usually play cards, but tonight he decided to. His friend put a large amount of money on the table. His friend thought Nikos was going to lose. Nikos thought he was going to lose.

But it didn’t happen like that.

Nikos won. Then he played another game, and he won that one too. Then somebody asked him to play a game of dice, and Nikos won that as well. He won quite a lot of money. ‘Go on then, Nikos,’ his friends shouted, ‘use all the money you have won to buy some lottery tickets!’ Nikos spent all the money he had won on lottery tickets. The draw for the lottery was the next day.

The next day after work Nikos went to the taverna again. Everybody was watching the draw for the lottery on TV. The first number came out, for the third prize. It was Nikos’ number. Then the second number, for the second prize. It was another of Nikos’ tickets. Then the first prize. It was Nikos’ number as well. He won all three of the big lottery prizes.

It was incredible. It seemed that all the things that people thought caused bad luck actually brought him good luck.

The next day Nikos bought a book about superstitions from all over the world. When he had read the book he decided to do everything that would bring him bad luck. He left empty bottles on the table. He asked his wife to cut his hair for him. He accepted a box of knives as a gift. He slept with his feet pointing towards the door. He sat on the corners of tables. He put a candle in front of the mirror. He always left his hat on the bed. He always left his wallet on the bed. He bought things in numbers of six or thirteen. He crossed people on the stairs. He got on a boat and whistled. And with everything he did, he got luckier and luckier. He won the lottery again. He won the games of dice in the taverna every evening. The things got crazier and crazier. He bought a black cat as a pet. He broke a few more mirrors, on purpose. He didn’t look people in the eye when they raised their glasses to him. He put loaves of bread upside down on the table. He spilled salt. He spilled olive oil. He spilled wine.

The more superstitious things he did, the luckier he became. He went into the taverna and started to tell all his friends what he thought.

‘You see!’ he told them. ‘I was right all along! Superstition is nonsense! The more things I do to break ridiculous superstitions, the more lucky I am!’

‘But Nikos,’ replied one of his friends, ‘don’t you see that you are actually as superstitious as we are? You are so careful to break superstitions, and this brings you luck. But you are only lucky when you do these things. Your disbelief is actually a kind of belief!’

Nikos thought hard about what his friend said. He had to admit that it was true. He was so careful to break all the superstitions he could, that in some way he was actually observing those superstitions.

The next day, he stopped spilling salt, chasing away black cats, walking under ladders, putting up umbrellas in the house and breaking mirrors. He also stopped winning money on the lottery. He started to lose at games of cards or dice.

He was a normal man again. Sometimes he was lucky, sometimes he wasn’t. He didn’t not believe in superstitions any more, but he didn’t believe in them either.

‘Nikos,’ said his friend to him, ‘it was your belief in yourself that made you lucky. It was your self-confidence that helped you, not superstitions.’

Nikos listened to his friend and thought that he was right. But however rational he still believed himself to be, he always wondered what would have happened if he hadn’t broken that mirror …

Chris Rose



Language level

Intermediate: B1


In my country the more common superstitions are: Break mirrors and have a black cat. This story is very interesting; I love this page!

Sorry I mad a mistake in this phrase: I never read his storyes. That's better. I think.

Hi Steffuller. Yes shure I seem that in many country are the same superstitions. In my country it is. I like how Cris Rouse writes. I have never ritten him and now, he my favorit writer.

This article is very intrestin. Hanestly I seem that don't need hear some people because you are begining to become as they an ordinary man. I think you must go your way and to hear nothing. But anyway the ladders should walking around!

I'm confused in the sentence in braces from the below paragraph:
He was a normal man again. Sometimes he was lucky, sometimes he wasn’t. (He didn’t not believe in superstitions any more, but he didn’t believe in them either.)

Hello mohitm,

It is an unusual sentence, isn't it? It uses a non-standard form for rhetorical effect.

The double negative is He didn't not believe and it is contrasted with the normal negative later in the sentence, which is he didn't believe.

The sentence means that he had stopped being a non-believer, but he wasn't a believer either. As I said, it is a non-standard and unusual form.



The LearnEnglish Team

Well, I think this superstition story is very good to improve my English skills.
I´m a superstition too and I know that I´ll only be fluent in English, if I practice reading and listening.
It was really good to find this web site.

Well, I think this story is interesting and helpful for those people who stydy English, particularly the past tenses.
I have superstitions about the number 4 because sometimes I have bad luck when I see it. In my country, people avoid combing hair when they are in a car, they belive that doing this thing would cause bad luck on the trip.

Hi there,

Great story, but I have a couple of questions about the questions.

For example:

1. Especially good things or especially bad things
a. aren’t happening to Nikos
b. didn’t happen to Nikos
c. won’t happen to Nikos
d. wouldn’t have happened to Nikos

The sheet says that 'b' is the correct answer, but why is that the case? He won lots of money so isn't that something especially good happening to Nikos? You write 'or' which means the statement applies to either not both. Is this just to test grammar, even though the answers do not reflect the events of the story? This seems a little confusing.

2. Nikos didn’t believe that
a. his luck could be changed by superstitious events
b. his luck was changed by superstitious events
c. his luck should be changed by superstitious events
d. his luck would be changed by superstitious events

The sheet says that 'b' is the correct answer, but what is stopping 'a' from being the correct answer? At the start of the story, Nikos didn't believe that his luck could be changed by superstitious events. Or 'd', Nikos also didn't believe that his luck would be changed by superstitious events?

Is there something I am missing?

Many thanks.

1. Especially good...
Ans. didn't happen to Nikos.
Solution : because it's talking about the very first life of Nikos, i.e. when he was just a normal man. Hence, neither very good not very bad happened to him.
You seem to have taken it as the subsequent about-face caused to him afterwards when he got very lucky and things just flick over very good.

2. Nikos didn't....
Ans. his luck was...
Why is it so?
I mean it is about EXACTLY what happened to Nikos AFTERWARDS. He tried all the things but didn't believe they were the consequences of his actions that he performed.

Moreover, this whole reading was just about Reporting.
That's why it is all about changing verb forms according to their timings.
In addition to that, modal verbs, they also affected the mood of the questions.
How I dealt with them was I merely tried to compare the questions to their given options.
That way, I was able to score 7/8.
If you have difficulties for finding right things in refer to the grammar section of the British Council LearnEnglish, specifically pointing which grammar section you're facing problems for.
Have a nice day!